Urban Legend Series: Moths as Human Souls (Part 6 of 7)

¡@

2.0 SPI Investigates and Debunks the Myth


Are moths really vehicles for souls to return and haunt you?

2.1 Do moths or butterflies bring the soul of the deceased to visit the living?

Moths and butterflies appearing in living spaces after the death of a family member may be a sign that the soul of the recently deceased is paying the family a visit. But is it really paying the family a visit or it is just attracted by our activities?

SPI's research has revealed that the list of items and practices in a place of mourning are magnets that attract moths and butterflies. The following table is observations of common mourning activities and rituals and how they attract the attention of moths and butterflies.


2.2 Light Disorientation Theories

TMoths are positively phototactic, meaning they automatically move toward light. Phototaxis is an organism's automatic movement toward or away from light. This is why moths are charmed by the presence of artificial lights such as florescent lamp from your house and outdoor camp fire, even if it leads to their untimely demise (known as ). Cockroaches are an example of a negatively phototactic organism. You have probably noticed how they scurry back into dark corners and crevices when you illuminate their late-night snacking party in your kitchen.

Moths are more sensitive to some wavelengths of light -- ultraviolet, for example -- than they are to others. A white light will attract more moths than a yellow light. Yellow is a wavelength moths don't respond to.

Why are moths attracted to the light of a flame? The general consensus is that they are not actually attracted to light but are confused and disoriented by it. The reason why is open to debate on amongst lepidopterists (those who study moths and butterflies).

Some cite a theoretical phenomenon called the Loeb contraction, an inhibition of muscular action reportedly observed in some animals on the side nearest bright light. This could produce a ball-and-chain effect. A moth encountering a light to one side would become "weaker" on that side; the opposing "stronger" wings would push it toward the light.

Still another theory explains that moths perceive a false dark region around intense light - a night-flying insect's version of a watery desert mirage - and fly toward if to escape the glare. Others postulate that certain light frequencies invoke the same come-hither electrochemical responses in male moths as do female-moth sex pheromones. This at least could explain a moth's apparent willingness to plunge into flame.

The following are some possible theories

2.2.1 Mistaken for the moon during navigation

Some types of moths are known to migrate, and it's possible that the night sky gives them navigational directions. Some believe that because moths navigate by maintaining a constant angle to the moon or a star. With the presence of other visible bright lights that outshine the rather distant cosmic body, a moth would be disorientated and steer towards one of these lights in a gradual spiral inward flight path.

A moth's up-down orientation might also be dependent in part on the brightness of the sky relative to the ground. Some lepidopterists suggest that moths use the moon as a primary reference point and have the ability to calibrate their flight paths as the Earth's rotation causes the moon to move across the sky. (There is even evidence to support the theory that migrating moths have an internal geomagnetic compass system to guide them in the right direction.) Therefore, a moth's attraction to an artificial light or to a fire could be related to orientation, and lead to dis?orientation -- the moth wasn't "expecting" to actually get to "the moon" (the light source) or to be able to fly above it, so confusion results.


2.2.2 Mistaken for escape route

It is possible that moths have an escape-route mechanism related to light. Imagine disturbing a bush full of moths at night - they all fly up and out of the bush, toward the sky. To a moth in danger, flying toward the light (which is usually in the sky, or at least upward) tends to be a more advantageous response than flying toward darkness (which is usually downward). When flying towards a bright source of light, whatever that may be chasing the moth would be blinded by the light ahead. Flying into darkness however, would not provide any advantages to an escaping moth.


2.2.3 Confused by bright light

Another interesting question is: Why do moths stay around sources of lights? A moth's eyes, like a human's eyes, contain light sensors and adjust according to the amount of light the sensors detect. In high illumination, light from each of the moth's thousands of fixed-focus lens facets is channeled to its own sensor (ommatidium). In low illumination, light from multiple lenses is channeled to the same ommatidium to increase light sensitivity. You probably experience a few moments of blindness when you turn on a bright light after your eyes have adjusted to darkness, or when you are suddenly in darkness after being in bright light. A moth's dark-adapting mechanism responds much more slowly than its light-adapting mechanism. Once the moth comes close to a bright light, it might have a hard time leaving the light since going back into the dark renders it blind and vulnerable for a long period of time.

Here is a news on mass suicide of moth in Beijing. Hundreds of moths were toasted by the confusion of the bright spot lights.



2.3 Scent disorientation theories

2.3.1 Moth plants / flowers

A strong attractant to moths is a sex pheromone. The male pheromone consists of a mixture of a rare form of linalool, which is a sweet-smelling oil otherwise found only in coriander seeds--and cresols, a component of a coal tar.

Linalool is a naturally-occurring terpene alcohol chemical found in many flowers and spice plants, the majority of which are based on its pleasant scent (floral, with a touch of spiciness). Over 200 species of plants produce linalool, mainly from the families Lamiaceae (mints, scented herbs), Lauraceae (laurels, cinnamon, rosewood) and Rutaceae (citrus fruits).

It is interesting to note that many of the chemical compounds identified from male pheromones are also common components of the scents of flowers. Rushcliffe Borough Council, in US has published a list of plants which attract wildlife including of course moth.





Moths visit flowers in search of nutritious nectar. Indeed, flowering plants have also evolved to make full use of such behaviour by allowing pollen to come into direct contact with moths. As a result moths would transfer the pollen from flower to flower as they forge between clusters flowers. Most species of moths are nectar feeders and are attracted to highly scented flowers. However, flowers are also a large part of funeral services, and we see them aplenty during Qing Ming. In other words, we make funeral services and Qing Ming an attractive place for moths to feed.

2.3.2 Scents, sugar treats and fruits (Pear Ester)

Scientists, Entomologists Douglas Light and Alan Knight, from US Agricultural Research Service discovered that a chemical in the form of pear ester attracts moths. In an academic report published by University of California in August 2008, it is found that moths have apparently evolved to detect this ester odour and use it to locate a preferred food like ripening pears to lay eggs. Pears have just the right scent to attract codling moths that are brown colour and one of the most common kinds of moths.

Pheromones are chemicals that female moths give off to attract males for mating. Unlike pheromones that only attract male moths, the novel chemical attracts both sexes. Pear ester may be a stronger attractant than pheromones, which can be readily found in ripening pears. Indeed, many esters have distinctive fruit-like odours, which have led to their commonplace use in artificial flavourings and fragrances.


Moths feeding on fruits

Also, many moth-watchers are familiar with homebrewed "sugar" baits as a tried and tested method to attract moths. The bait or attractant is a gooey mixture of assorted sweet and fermented ingredients for which night fliers have a fondness. There are all sorts of sugar recipes. Here is a classic, proven formula according to Mother Earth News (February/March 2005 page 32):

  • 3 to 6 overripe bananas

  • Half to 1 cup molasses, corn syrup, honey or sugar

  • 1 to 2 cups orange juice or other fruit juice
  • 1 or 2 bottles stale beer or wine
  • 1 to 2 ounces rum

Mash or blend the bananas first, then stir in the sugary ingredients. Add the liquids last, a little at a time, until the mixture is about as thick as house paint. If it becomes too thin, just add another banana or two. Finally, put the mixture in a jar or bowl, cover it and leave it to ferment in the sun for a few hours.

This is just a basic recipe and one can improvise on it. Some cooks do not include alcoholic ingredients, and instead add apple cider vinegar to the brew. Others swear by certain liquors (e.g. Ron Bacardi) or kinds of juices that mimic those of local fruit trees (cherry and apple juices are popular). In any case, the objective is to produce a highly aromatic, cloyingly sweet and somewhat potent goo that is irresistible to moths.



Moth traps are commonly made of light, sugary treats and ripe fruits to capture moths at night by the hobbiests


References:

  • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ester#Structure_and_physical_properties

  • A detailed report can be found at University of Oregon State Website: http://extension.oregonstate.edu/catalog/pdf/em/em8904.pdf

  • Another important report "Fruit Perfume Lures Female Codling Moths": http://www.ars.usda.gov/is/AR/archive/jun01/moth0601.htm

Main Menu
Table of Content
<< Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next >>



Should you have any comment about this SPI Article, we would like to hear from you by email.
¡@

All the photos are the property of SPI. Illegal copying is strictly prohibited.
Published by Singapore Paranormal Investigators
All rights reserved (C) 2002-2009 www.spi.com.sg